Political
Humor under Stalin: an Anthology of Unofficial Jokes and Anecdotes,
edited by David Brandenberger (Bloomington: Slavica, forthcoming
2007)
prospectus
Political
Humor under Stalin is an anthology of jokes, wisecracks and
satire from the Soviet 1930s and '40s that provides a glimpse of
everyday dissembling and dissent in one of the modern world's most
repressive societies. More than merely a joke book, Political
Humor under Stalin offers no less than a counter-narrative
to the "official" history of the USSR, spread across ten
thematic chapters that have been fully annotated for maximum accessibility.
Political Humor under Stalin also features a ground-breaking
introductory discussion of the culture of joke-telling under Stalin,
analyzing the nature of the era's political humor and the context
within which jokes were (and were not) told. The first book of its
kind, Political Humor under Stalin addresses a long-neglected
subject in Soviet cultural and social history that promises to attract
considerable attention in the interdisciplinary field of Russian
studies.
problematica
Political
Humor under Stalin begins with a sweeping investigation of
joke-telling during the darkest years of the Russian twentieth century.
Taking advantage of an array of little-known sources (archival documents,
diaries, memoirs and refugee interviews), the volume's introduction
examines Stalin-era humor as a practice, detailing the context in
which political joking took place and determining what led Soviet
citizens to indulge in such a risky pastime. The introduction also
outlines the party's campaign to suppress political humor--both
its condemnation of joke-telling and its persecution of the jokesters
themselves--in order to explain why the Soviet leadership reacted
so hysterically to even the most innocent of wisecracks.
The core of this study consists of some 350 Stalin-era jokes, arranged
into chapters and laid out in split-face format in Russian and English.
Based on a little-known collection published in Munich in 1951,[1]
Political Humor under Stalin presents the material in English
translation along with explanatory notes and extensive cross-referencing
against other Stalin-era sources. This cross-referencing not only
confirms the authenticity of the volume's contents, but also hints
at the pervasiveness of political humor in the society as a whole.
Ultimately, Political Humor under Stalin challenges popular
assumptions about the 1930s and '40s by demonstrating the existence
of an underground culture of joke-telling in a society long thought
to have been thoroughly cowed by the secret police. Indeed, this
volume reveals that despite the enforcement of legal statutes punishing
jokesters for "anti-Soviet agitation" (the Soviet criminal
code's notorious Article 58/10), political humor played a vital
role in everyday life during the Stalin era.
existing
literature and potential audience
Although
a number of collections of Soviet humor have been published in the
last thirty years, they have always been based on jokes that circulated
after the Khrushchev "Thaw."[2] Political Humor under
Stalin is the first full-scale investigation of joke-telling
during the preceding period, drawing attention to a little-understood
subculture of Stalinism that few have ever suspected even existed.
Humor itself is a serious subject of inquiry in cultural studies
and similar books have been published in the past ten years on the
culture of political humor in Nazi Germany, Communist Rumania, ancient
Rome and other equally unlikely places. One study has even looked
at the grim history of Jewish humor during the Holocaust.[3] Political
Humor under Stalin extends this analysis of popular resistance
and dissembling to Stalinist society between the 1930s and '40s,
filling an important niche in the developing literature on Soviet
social and cultural history.
A short manuscript of roughly 50,000 words, Political Humor
under Stalin has obvious appeal for both specialists and non-specialists.
It also has considerable potential in the classroom as a reader
on twentieth-century Russian history and culture--I've used the
material myself for years with great success. My colleagues and
I believe Political Humor under Stalin could be successfully
marketed as an inexpensive paperback text for introductory Russian
history surveys, upper-level Stalinism seminars and interdisciplinary
culture courses taught on the graduate-level in either English or
Russian. Unusually accessible for a primary source text, Political
Humor under Stalin could compete well with more traditional
readers such as James von Geldern and Richard Stites' Mass Culture
in Soviet Russia, Ronald Grigor Suny's The Structure of
Soviet History, and the Annals of Communism series published
by Yale University Press.[4]
significance
Long
overlooked by scholars, the political humor of the Stalin era has
direct bearing on ongoing debates over the nature of conformity,
indoctrination, dissent and resistance in the USSR during the 1930s
and '40s. It also has a role to play in the larger field of Russian
social and cultural history, insofar as political joking and satire
are already established subjects of inquiry in many other fields.
A neglected topic with enormous potential, Soviet joke-telling provides
a glimpse of a repressive society that few have ever imagined. Political
Humor under Stalin showcases such material in an appealing
and accessible way that will find a broad readership in the field
of Russian studies.
notes
[1]
Kreml' i narod, ed. E. Andreevich (Munich: [Golos naroda,]
1951).
[2]
Emil A. Draitser, Making War, not Love: Gender and Sexuality
in Russian Humor (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1999); idem,
Taking Penguins to the Movies: Ethnic Humor in Russia (Detroit:
Wayne State UP, 1998); Zhdanna Dolgopolova, Russia Dies Laughing:
Jokes from Soviet Russia (London: Andre Deutsch, 1982); P.
Beckmann, Hammer and Tickle: Clandestine Laughter in the Soviet
Empire (Boulder: Golem, 1980); etc.
[3]
Underground Humor in Nazi Germany, 1933-1945, ed. F. K.
L. Hillenbrand (New York: Routledge, 1995); Anthony Corbeill, Controlling
Laughter: Political Humor in the Late Roman Republic (Princeton:
Princeton UP, 1996); Steve Lipman, Laughter in Hell: the Uses
of Humor during the Holocaust (Northvale: Jason Aronson, 1991).
[4]
Mass Culture in Soviet Russia: Tales, Poems, Songs, Movies,
Plays, and Folklore, 1917-1953, eds. James von Geldern and
Richard Stites (Bloomington: Indiana UP, 1995); The Structure
of Soviet History: Essays and Documents, ed. Ronald Grigor
Suny (Oxford: Oxford UP, 2002); Stalinism as a Way of Life:
a Narrative in Documents, eds. Lewis Siegelbaum and Andrei
Sokolov (New Haven: Yale UP, 2000).