An Election Town Meeting

A WebQuest for High School Students Studying American Government

Designed by
Nicholas Barlett and Brian Letourneau

Introduction | Task | Process | Evaluation | Conclusion | Credits
Teacher Page | Credits/References
 

Introduction

The election process offers U.S. citizens the opportunity to alter government in ways that reflect the needs of society.  This tremendously important part of the American political system must be supported by well informed members of the community.  People develop different views of those campaigning for election as the candidates tell about their views on important issues.  It is on the issues that citizens choose the candidate who best represents their needs.  In order to attract voters the candidates may hold a town meeting where they explain their stance on the issues.  These town meetings draw people of all types who want to find out who is the best representative of their needs.

It is in this setting that you and your fellow citizens will come together to carry out your own town meeting.  Each of the members will take on the roles of certain characters in this town meeting.  Your job will be to develop an understanding of the needs of the character whom you take.

The purpose of this project is to develop an understanding of where the political parties stand on different issues and what parts of society tend to find a candidate appealing.  By  researching the background of the candidates in the town meeting and matching them with the needs of the citizens you will develop an understanding of why it is important to become a more informed citizen as well as learning how to go about becoming informed.

Image courtesy of Al Gore's Election Homepage


Image courtesy of Ronald Reagan Presidential Library

Image courtesy of  George Bush's Election Homepage

The Task

The election process is central to the continuation of our strong democractic government.  Since elections are so important your goal is to participate in a town meeting as a specific member of society.  While in this role you should analyse political issues and evaluate the ways that these issues effect the populace.  With the information gathered you will formulate positions that you must defend.


Return to Top

The Process
 
This project will involve five students who will examine the aspects of the presidential election from different viewpoints and then come back together to hold a town meeting/debate. One student will play the role of a Democratic candidate for president while another will portray a Republican candidate for the same position. The other three students will take on the roles of citizens representing different segments of society. One will play the part of an Upper Class businessman. Another will portray the views of a middle class minority mother. Finally, the third will depict the positions of a lower class blue-collar worker. Once each individual has a clear understanding of their role, the group will come back together for a town meeting/debate. Each candidate will prepare a short introductory speech summing up their views on issues they deem to be the most prevalent. Then, the citizens will ask questions of the candidates to determine more specifically how they would act in certain instances, define stances on issues not addressed in introductory speeches, and spark a debate between the two candidates. The citizens must prepare a position statement, in the form of an essay, on the issues that are most important to that specific segment of society.

You will have four (4) days to complete this project. The first day will cover the introduction and allow the students to familiarize themselves with the issues and positions that they will be representing. The second day will allow for the citizens to prepare their position statements and the candidates time to work on their speeches. The third day will be for the citizens to generate issue based questions to ask the candidates during the debate and for the candidates to prepare responses to questions that they think will be asked by the public. On the fourth day, the town meeting will be held.

In order to successfully complete this task, you must do the following:

 
Before breaking up to work on your individual tasks, everyone should first look at the following sites to get a better idea of the nature of the issues that are currently under hot debate and an overall picture of the race.
  •  Boston Globe's Election Coverage - This is the Boston Globe's special section covering the 2000 Presidential election.
  •  Washington Post's Election Coverage - This is the Washington Post's extra section covering all the issues and events surrounding the upcoming Presidential Election.
  •  Los Angeles Times' Election Coverage - Extended coverage of the election is provided in this part of the Los Angeles Times.
  •  St. Louis Post-Dispatch's Election Coverage - The St. Louis Post- Dispatch's additional coverage of the presidential campaign.
  • Issues2000- This site is devoted to covering all of the major issues and each candidate's position on them.
  • In order for the town meeting to be successful in truly delving into the views of the candidates and constituents, there must be conflicting/opposing views represented by the participants. Therefore, each student shall take on a separate role in which he/she will represent the views of a broad section of society.  Please click on the links below to view these roles and their resources.

    Democratic Presidental Candidate

    Republican Presidential Candidate

    Citizen Representing the Views of an Upper Class Business Man

    Citizen Representing the Views of a Minority Working Mother of the Middle Class

    Citizen Representing the Views of a Low Income Blue-Collar Worker

    Return to Top
     
     

    Evaluation
     

    Students will be evaluated using one of the two rubrics provided below depending on which role the student assumes.

    Scoring Rubric for Citizens:

    Level of Accomplishment
    Beginning 
    Developing
    Accomplished
    Score
    (Highest Possible Score=10)
    Position Paper
    60%
    2 points

    Stances on positions are poorly defined and the student offers little support; grammar and spelling weak.

    4 points

    Student clearly defines stances on issues, but support is weak or inconsistent in areas; some grammar and spelling mistakes.

    6 points

    Student clearly defines stances on issues and offers logical, well thought out support for their points; proper use of grammar and minimal spelling errors.

    Maximum 6 points
    Questions
    40%
    1.5 points

    Questions are superfiicial in nature and poorly articulated.

    2.5 points

    Questions display some thought about the topic and its ramifications; articulation is satisfactory.

    4 points

    Questions display a great deal of understanding about the topic and are well articulated.

    Maximum 4 points
    Scoring Rubric for Candidates:
    Level of Accomplishment
    Beginning
    Developing
    Accomplished
    Score
    (Highest Possible Score=10)
    Speech
    60%
    2 points

    Explanation of stance on issues displays little understanding of the topic and many positions  are inconsistent; presentation is poorly articulated.

    4 points

    Explanation of stances on issues displays some understanding/thought of the topic with few inconsistencies; articulation of presentation is satisfactory.

    6 points

    Speech shows a great understanding of the topic and displays a formidable knowledge of the issues; presentation is clear, concise, and well articulated.

    Maximum 6 points
    Responses to Questions
    40%
    1.5 points

    Question is evaded, answer is not defined, or support lacks substance; poorly articulated.

    2.5 points

    Response is well defined, however, support is lacking or is inconsistent; articulation is satisfactory.

    4 points

    Response is well defined while the support is plentiful and consisten with candidate's views; presentation is clear, concise, and well articulated.

    Maximum 4 points

    Return to Top
     
     

    Conclusion
     
    By participating in this town meeting you should be prepared to make your decision on Election Day.  Your analysis and evaluation of the topics and issues that effect the election process will make you a more informed voter.  Now that you have played either a candidate or an involved citizen it is your turn to become an active member of the political system.  Find out what issues are important to you, take an active role in supporting your beliefs, and lobby against what is unjust.